The Supreme Court of India has made a significant statement regarding the country’s stance on cryptocurrencies. The Court emphasized that an outright ban on digital assets is unrealistic, and instead stressed the need for a clear and effective legal framework. Justice Surya Kant stated that the government has fallen short in regulating the sector, which poses serious economic risks.
This assessment from the Supreme Court serves as a clear warning against the longstanding regulatory uncertainty surrounding crypto in India. One of the main issues highlighted by the judiciary is the fact that this sector, which has been primarily controlled through taxation policies, still lacks a proper legal foundation.
“You Tax It But Don’t Regulate It”
Justice Kant pointed out the 30% tax imposed on crypto gains and criticized the contradiction of the government profiting from a sector it fails to regulate. He stated that cryptocurrencies are currently creating a sort of “parallel economy” in the country, which could have dangerous implications for the broader economy.
Speaking during an ongoing case related to Bitcoin transactions, Justice Kant emphasized the following:
Key Issues Raised by the Supreme Court:
- The government collects taxes from crypto income but fails to establish a legal regulatory framework.
- The uncontrolled growth of cryptocurrencies increases the risks of money laundering and tax evasion.
- A complete ban is not a viable solution, as it is technologically difficult to enforce and practically ineffective.
- The government previously stated it would publish a consultation paper, but this has yet to be released to the public.
- The current uncertainty creates a risky environment for both investors and companies in terms of sustainability.
Government Signals Possible Review
In response to the Court’s criticism, India’s Additional Solicitor General—representing the government—hinted that the current policies could be reviewed. Responding with the words, “We will take instructions, sir,” the Solicitor General indicated that India’s crypto policy may be reconsidered.
This dialogue suggests that the Indian government may soon be compelled to take more concrete steps on cryptocurrency regulation and may signal the introduction of a new regulatory framework to be presented to the public.
